Making Employment A Reality
Saturday, February 5th, 2005
© Dale Susan Brown
I experienced job discrimination first-hand eight years ago. I had just started a self-help group for people with learning disabilities and appeared on television speaking as a person with a learning disability.
The word got back to my office. Now, as my disability is invisible, I had found my first job through routine channels. I was considered an excellent worker and received pay increases each year. My job, however, was a contract job and was soon to end. I applied for another job within the same company. Due to my documented high performance, I was confident that I was a top contender for the new job. So I felt very hopeful when the woman who was interviewing called me into her office.
“I’m sorry, Dale, but I have bad news,” she said. “I can’t hire you. I’m concerned about your learning disability.”
I was shocked. I looked at her. I said nothing. Finally, after a few moments of numb silence, I said, “I think you’ve made a mistake. I don’t think my learning disabilities have anything to do with whether or not I can do the job. I would like to discuss this later.” Then I left.
I wrote her a letter explaining that I could do the job well and expressing surprise that a person of her caliber in an agency as humanitarian as the one where I worked could knowingly discriminate. I spent several months writing her letters, having long talks with her, and persuading her that she would work well with me.
Interestingly enough, I never went above her head or used legal action. How did I persuade her?
Although I had not yet heard of them, I used techniques recommended by Richard Pimental. Pimentel is Executive Vice President, Milt Wright and Associates (Windmill Training Group), which has trained thousands of employers on equal opportunity for people with disabilities. He recently developed a training program for applicants with disabilities. Here are some of his findings.
“It’s not the best-qualified applicant who gets the job. The decision to hire is the decision to like someone. The applicant with a disability must present the right image and that’s hard, because when the employer without a disability meets someone with a disability, the disability becomes the overriding factor.” In my case, my disability was not an issue, until I appeared on television discussing my self-help group. People with visible disabilities face this issue at each meeting they have with each person.
“Being turned down for a job is not a personal decision, but a personnel decision. It’s not a reflection on your value as a human being. Disabled people have to become stronger with each rejection, not weaker.
Unfortunately, that is easier said than done. I was very upset when I heard my supervisor’s words. If an able-bodied person were discriminated against for having red hair, that person would be indignant and angry. He or she would easily be able to set the other person straight. However, I had been criticized and put down in so many ways, so many times, that a part of me believed that I was not fit to work at that company. I blew every small mistake I made out of proportion. I felt guilty. I blamed myself for being discriminated against. This process of internalizing the negative words of others is typical of people from any minority group which has been oppressed.
I had to ignore these feelings and act on the facts which were that I was a good worker and could do the job, provided I got the new job. That meant persistently requesting the job, despite repeated rejections. It meant being sure I spoke calmly and confidently, without anger or tentatitiveness. I had to look at my boss carefully, neither lowering my eyes with shame nor glaring with disrespect. I couldn’t bow my head. And I had to listen to what she had to say and respond to her fears.
Pimental recommends these steps:
“Anticipate what the employer might think about people with this disability,” Pimental suggests. “Appreciate their concerns. Show that you know the employer is not an evil person, but reacting the same way anyone might react. Then explain how the fear is not valid and give the solution.”
For example, I said, “I can understand how you might be concerned that I can’t read small print. That is true of some people with learning disabilities. However, it isn’t true for me. I can read small print and do not have a reading disability.
“When it comes to the point you raised about my memory, however, you are right. I don’t have the best memory in the world. Let me show you the checklists and systems I use for keeping track of details…..”
I responded to every issue she brought up in conversation. Then, I summed up our discussions in written letters I mailed to her. I appealed to her sense of fair play. It worked. She took me to lunch and offered me the job. We had a good relationship despite this rough start.
My experience is just one small example of how we can market our disabilities successfully to employers. We have to be prepared to answer all the doubts and concerns about our disabilities in addition to demonstrating that we have the right job skills. We need to build our confidence and we can do this through self-help groups and role playing. Above all, we need to keep at it, to press for the job that we know we can do. Neither my boss nor I regret my hiring. It was a positive experience for both of us.
Author’s Note: This story, regarding a discrimination experience I had with my first long-term job, was published and distributed nationally in 1987 as part of the National Employ the Handicapped Week Kit of the President’s Committee on Employment of People with Disabilities.
If the HR person actually said: “I’m sorry, Dale, but I have bad news,‚Äù…‚ÄúI can‚Äôt hire you. I‚Äôm concerned about your learning disability.‚Äù it sounds like a clear case of ilegal discrimination under the ADA.
Why don’t you appeal for redress under the ADA?
Heather Dunbar
Van Etten NY
i think that it was wrong the way dale was treated . im glad that it is sorted out and that she got the job she deserved. i disagree with her employers as whenever they found out about her eyes their tunes changed they had concerns about weather or not she could do the job but if she was a fantastic worker before they found out about her eyes then shes still going to be a fantastic workere nothing changes. or sorry nothing should change. i can understand what it would be like as i have a problem wioth my eyesite to and i know that i am going to be discriminated against whenever i go out and look for a full time job. but im glad that you get stronger every time you get rejected that has biult my confidence.
Thank you for understanding the article and what I was trying to say. And congratulations for getting stronger each time you are discrminated against. Remember that Job Accommodation Network 1-800-526-7234 can help you think through what to do and also with ways you can do the job.
Where can I find for my 38 yr. old daughter who has executive functioning problems an advocate or who can pinpoint exactly where she can fit into the workplace. She has a college degree from the U. of A. in their L.D. program that they had which prepared her for absolutely nothing and for twenty years she has tried and so have her parents to support her and think that she could fly on her own. It is now apparent that she can not through a series of failures and rejections. She needs a person who can be her advocate to get through the system and help her to be independent and be in the workforce…(is there a specific person or specific agency that with given a medical report can pinpoint exactly what type of work she can do and a network to find her a job in that capacity. She is well read, intelligent and has been in denial for a long time that she can’t do what other people can do in the workplace. So….she has not succeeded and has been let go. Going to an L.D. support sites generally offer general information to parents with children…and doesn’t address the specific problems encountered and specific help available for adults who are lost in the cracks which is extremely frustrating that it is so general and not truly addressing people’s needs. She lives in Chicago.with her father because she can’t support herself..doesn’t have a car because she and we can’t support that…She went a few years ago to the IL voc. hab by herself and was lost in the shuffle of them changing social workers and never returning her calls. So the ball was dropped. Do you know a contact person that can really help her? Everything she has aspired to…after a short time…they see that she can’t do whatever is required and let her go. She is depressed and wants to be independent but needs to find 1) an advocate for her to give her some hope. 2) network of adults with similiar problems of executive functioning who she can e-mail or talk with that can help her deal with these frustrations of constant rejection. A social worker or someone to help her deal with this who works with L.D. adults. She does have a high anxiety level and gets frustrated and scattered very easily because something is amis. Can you help????